Re: [Bug-gne]Right/Wrong if editorship in GNE/Nupedia

[Mike Warren]

Tom Chance <address@hidden> writes:

> It would be good if people could correct articles and post those,
> but we'd have to be very very careful about this, and we can't be
> careful enough, so its unfeasible. What if I posted an article and
> somebody posted a "correction" that I disagreed with. I might then
> get a bit pissed off, and post a corection to their article, and so
> on. The resource could turn into a sort of discussion board for
> people's ideas. I think if people want to post another slant on an
> issue, it shouln't be viewed as a correction (because nobody can say
> it is more correct than the original) but rather just another
> article.

I agree; ``new versions'' of an article should only happen if the
original author(s) make the correction. Obviously, people can edit any
article they want and re-submit it, but these should get new
unique-IDs.

-- 
address@hidden
<URL:http://www.mike-warren.com>
GPG: 0x579911BD :: 87F2 4D98 BDB0 0E90 EE2A  0CF9 1087 0884 5799 11BD