Re: [Repo-criteria-discuss] Evals and press released published

[Mike Gerwitz]

On Mon, Apr 25, 2016 at 18:22:21 -0700, Aaron Wolf wrote:
> "Important site functionality does not work without running nonfree
> JavaScript" for Sourceforge. That's not even clear or valid! As far as
> we know, it might be free JS! The only thing we know is that the
> functions don't work with LibreJS active, and that's the criteria, right?
>
> Why is this so hard?

Sorry, I somehow decided to copy the part you didn't like instead of the
part you suggested; let me try this without distraction.  I'm using your
original suggested text:

signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

*** eval-page-draft-old.html    2016-04-25 20:40:29.890602588 -0400
--- eval-page-draft.html        2016-04-25 22:18:12.226870715 -0400
***************
*** 143,150 ****
  
  <ul>
    <li id="GitHub-C0">
!     Important site functionality does not work without running nonfree
!     JavaScript.
      (<a href="repo-criteria.html#C0">C0</a>)
    </li>
  
--- 143,149 ----
  
  <ul>
    <li id="GitHub-C0">
!     Important site functionality does not work with LibreJS enabled.
      (<a href="repo-criteria.html#C0">C0</a>)
    </li>
  
***************
*** 166,173 ****
  
  <ul>
    <li id="SourceForge-C0">
!     Important site functionality doesn't work without JavaScript, or with
!     LibreJS enabled. (<a href="repo-criteria.html#C0">C0</a>)
    </li>
  
    <li id="SourceForge-C2">Rejects users from certain countries.</li>
--- 165,172 ----
  
  <ul>
    <li id="SourceForge-C0">
!     Important site functionality does not work with LibreJS enabled.
!     (<a href="repo-criteria.html#C0">C0</a>)
    </li>
  
    <li id="SourceForge-C2">Rejects users from certain countries.</li>

signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

GNU ethical repository criteria evaluations

We maintain this evaluation report presenting the compliance level of repository services with the GNU ethical repository criteria. There are some criteria that we can’t possibly verify, in which case we accept the site maintainer’s word on the matter. This evaluation is done by volunteers coordinated by the Free Software Foundation, and you are welcome to contribute.

Site	Grade	Date	Criteria Version
GNU Savannah	A	2015-10-01	1.0
GitLab	C	2015-11-05	1.0
GitHub	F	2016-04-13	1.0
SourceForge	F	2015-10-07	1.0

GNU Savannah — A

Savannah has already acheived the highest grade for ethical hosting; these are the issues that would need to be addressed for it to earn extra credit. If you would like to volunteer to help make some of these changes, please join the Savannah team.

• There are normal Web access/download logs which sometimes include IP addresses. (A+1)
• It follows EFF’s criteria only partially; complying with the rest remains in progress. (A+2)
• HTML_CodeSniffer reports dozen of errors and warnings related to WCAG 2.0 compliance on every page. (A+3)
• There is no WAI-ARIA markup in its pages. (A+4)
• There is no way of exporting data contributed by project owners or contributors. (A+5)

GitLab — C

Things that prevent it from moving up to the next grade, B:

• All _javascript_ code served to the client is free, but does not work with LibreJS enabled. (B0)
• Encourages bad licensing practice, including no license; failure to state the license on each source file; and failure to say which GPL versions apply. (B2)

GitHub — F

Things that prevent it from moving up to the next grade, C:

• Important site functionality does not work with LibreJS enabled. (C0)
• Specific information may not be available in all countries; see roskomnadzor and export controls for more details. (C2)

SourceForge — F

Things that prevent it from moving up to the next grade, C:

• Important site functionality does not work with LibreJS enabled. (C0)
• Rejects users from certain countries.

Please send general FSF & GNU inquiries to <address@hidden>. There are also other ways to contact the FSF. Broken links and other corrections or suggestions can be sent to <address@hidden>.

Please see the Translations README for information on coordinating and submitting translations of this article.

Copyright © 2015 Free Software Foundation, Inc.

This page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Updated: $Date: 2015/05/18 06:12:54 $

signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

-- 
Mike Gerwitz
Free Software Hacker | GNU Maintainer & Volunteer
https://mikegerwitz.com
FSF Member #5804 | GPG Key ID: 0x8EE30EAB