[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
RE: Changing voice order...
From: |
Mark Stephen Mrotek |
Subject: |
RE: Changing voice order... |
Date: |
Thu, 27 Oct 2016 12:35:49 -0700 |
David,
Yes, in that order - usually only three voice.
This usually in "chord" that have a moving internal voice.
Lilypond, as you stated, adjust the note columns and stem suitably.
The only constant is change. The manual has been clearly written in the
past.
I can follow directions. Let the majority rule.
Mark
-----Original Message-----
From: David Kastrup [mailto:address@hidden
Sent: Thursday, October 27, 2016 11:52 AM
To: Mark Stephen Mrotek <address@hidden>
Cc: address@hidden
Subject: Re: Changing voice order...
"Mark Stephen Mrotek" <address@hidden> writes:
> David,
>
> Since starting Lilypond I have become accustomed to the order
> presented in the manual (2.18.2) that states:
> Voice 1: highest
> Voice 2: lowest
> Voice 3: second highest
> Voice 4: second lowest
> Voice 5: third highest
> Voice 6: third lowest.
>
> This arrangement is useful for my setting idiosyncratic piano (Chopin,
> Mendelssohn).
So you enter your material in that order? Particularly in connection with
<< ... \\ ... \\ ... ... >> ?
If you do, you are representative for users that _will_ be getting headaches
when we change this. I'm pretty sure that this is worth changing but I have
rather few ideas how we could make the transition less painful.
Maybe some switch/command that will revert to the old order? Then
convert-ly would provide it when detecting a << ... \\ ... \\ ... ... >>
construct and one would usually strive to edit the source in order to be
able to remove it again.
--
David Kastrup
Re: Changing voice order..., Carl Sorensen, 2016/10/27
Re: Changing voice order..., lilypond, 2016/10/27
RE: Changing voice order..., Mark Stephen Mrotek, 2016/10/27
- Re: Changing voice order..., David Kastrup, 2016/10/27
- RE: Changing voice order...,
Mark Stephen Mrotek <=
- Re: Changing voice order..., David Kastrup, 2016/10/27
- RE: Changing voice order..., Mark Stephen Mrotek, 2016/10/27
- Re: Changing voice order..., David Kastrup, 2016/10/27
- RE: Changing voice order..., Mark Stephen Mrotek, 2016/10/27
- Re: Changing voice order..., Michael Gerdau, 2016/10/27
- RE: Changing voice order..., Mark Stephen Mrotek, 2016/10/27
- Re: Changing voice order..., Vaughan McAlley, 2016/10/28
- Re: Changing voice order..., Michael Gerdau, 2016/10/28
Re: Changing voice order..., David Kastrup, 2016/10/28
Re: Changing voice order..., Noeck, 2016/10/27