Re: Correct ordering of items in mail threads

[Pankaj Jangid]

Adam Sjøgren <asjo@koldfront.dk> writes:

> Pankaj writes:
>
>> E   20-10-23 23:18 PM [ 107: Victor Giordano ] => Re: [go-nuts] Re: About 
>> allowing conversion from bool to int
>> O   21-10-23 02:44 AM [ 123: Victor Giordano ]   +-> 
>> O   21-10-23 03:17 AM [ 142: Volker Dobler   ]     +-> 
>> O   21-10-23 06:01 AM [  21: Ian Lance Taylor]     +-> 
>> O   21-10-23 08:44 AM [  57: Victor Giordano ]       +-> 
>> E   21-10-23 18:27 PM [  69: Victor Giordano ]         +-> 
>> O   21-10-23 03:44 AM { 179: Victor Giordano }           +-> Fwd: [go-nuts] 
>> Re: About allowing conversion from bool to int
>>
>> In the above snapshot, items are still ordered incorrectly.
>
> Just to make sure: you are expecting the article in the last row to be
> shown in the 4th row?

No. I want the indentation to be proper. It cannot be child of a later message.

> I would expect the reason that the last line is put last is because
> the References: header includes the Message-ID of the second to last
> article.
>
> Is that not the case?

As we can see this is not possible. Becase the second last message came
after the last one.

> But wait, the curly braces means "adopted". What does that mean?
>
>  · https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_node/gnus/Loose-Threads.html
>
> What happens if you change the value of gnus-summary-make-false-root?
> Perhaps to nil?

Wow. Good pointer. The default value of the variable is 'adopt'. I
experimented with the other three possible values. And here are the
results, along with the quoted docstring

> If this variable is ‘adopt’, Gnus will make one of the "children"
> the parent and mark all the step-children as such.

> If this variable is ‘none’, Gnus will not make a false root, but just
> present the sub-threads after another.

(setq gnus-summary-make-false-root 'none)

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
E   20-10-23 23:18 PM [ 107: Victor Giordano ] => Re: [go-nuts] Re: About 
allowing conversion from bool to int
O   21-10-23 02:44 AM [ 123: Victor Giordano ] | +-> 
O   21-10-23 03:17 AM [ 142: Volker Dobler   ] |   +-> 
O   21-10-23 06:01 AM [  21: Ian Lance Taylor] |   +-> 
O   21-10-23 08:44 AM [  57: Victor Giordano ] |     +-> 
E   21-10-23 18:27 PM [  69: Victor Giordano ] |       +-> 
O   21-10-23 03:44 AM [ 179: Victor Giordano ] => Fwd: [go-nuts] Re: About 
allowing conversion from bool to int
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

> If this variable is ‘dummy’, Gnus will create a dummy root that will
> have all the sub-threads as children.

(setq gnus-summary-make-false-root 'dummy)

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
   :                             : Re: [go-nuts] Re: About allowing conversion 
from bool to int
E   20-10-23 23:18 PM [ 107: Victor Giordano ] +-> 
O   21-10-23 02:44 AM [ 123: Victor Giordano ] | +-> 
O   21-10-23 03:17 AM [ 142: Volker Dobler   ] |   +-> 
O   21-10-23 06:01 AM [  21: Ian Lance Taylor] |   +-> 
O   21-10-23 08:44 AM [  57: Victor Giordano ] |     +-> 
E   21-10-23 18:27 PM [  69: Victor Giordano ] |       +-> 
O   21-10-23 03:44 AM [ 179: Victor Giordano ] +-> Fwd: [go-nuts] Re: About 
allowing conversion from bool to int
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

> If this variable is ‘empty’, the "children" are printed with empty
> subject fields.  (Or rather, they will be printed with a string given
> by the ‘gnus-summary-same-subject’ variable.)

(setq gnus-summary-make-false-root 'empty)

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
E   20-10-23 23:18 PM [ 107: Victor Giordano ] => Re: [go-nuts] Re: About 
allowing conversion from bool to int
O   21-10-23 02:44 AM [ 123: Victor Giordano ] | +-> 
O   21-10-23 03:17 AM [ 142: Volker Dobler   ] |   +-> 
O   21-10-23 06:01 AM [  21: Ian Lance Taylor] |   +-> 
O   21-10-23 08:44 AM [  57: Victor Giordano ] |     +-> 
E   21-10-23 18:27 PM [  69: Victor Giordano ] |       +-> 
O   21-10-23 03:44 AM [ 179: Victor Giordano ] => Fwd: [go-nuts] Re: About 
allowing conversion from bool to int
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

I think 'none' and 'empty' works best for the situation. May be I should
try each of these for a couple of days and decide.