Re: watchdog triggered auto-rollback

[Richard Sent]

raingloom@riseup.net writes:

> Would others find this useful?  Where in the stack would this be solved?
>  Could we, for example, catch an issue in the init system and still
> perform a rollback?  Or if not a full rollback, then at least a reboot
> into the previous config?  (And if that is also broken, then the one
> before, etc, etc)
>
> Obviously there are a lot of edge cases and potential bugs in this
> mechanism as well.  Sticking with the SSH example, rolling back to a
> version that was kept around where the authorized keys are different
> would also make the machine unreachable via SSH.

I would definitely find this useful, particularly when combined with
unattended-upgrade-service. I don't know the best way to handle an init
system failure.

Perhaps a starting point would be a one-shot
conditional-rollback-service with a "shepherd-requirements" field and a
"test" field that takes an file-like object. This service would execute
that file, write the output to some log file, and trigger a rollback if
an error is signaled.

Presumably this service should only trigger on boot, not reconfigure so
we don't risk running the test with old services. I don't believe Guix
has a mechanism yet to say "Yes, this service is new, and I /do/ want
Shepherd to auto-start it, but not on reconfigure". This shouldn't be
too hard to add though.

-- 
Take it easy,
Richard Sent
Making my computer weirder one commit at a time.