Re: [Qemu-stable] [Qemu-devel] [PATCH v2 0/2] docs/interop/bitmaps: rewrite and modernize doc

[John Snow]

On 4/23/19 2:10 PM, Vladimir Sementsov-Ogievskiy wrote:
> 23.04.2019 1:17, John Snow wrote:
>> The documentation as written in the 4.0 release is not quite correct as
>> of the 4.0 release; though thanks to backwards compatibility it's not
>> quite wrong either. It is suitable for inclusion in 4.0.1, or any
>> downstream that packages 4.0.
>>
>> This patch is an attempt at a nearly full rewrite that revitalizes this
>> document to address frequent questions I encounter when discussing the
>> API.
>>
>> V2:
>>    - Split off makefile change into its own little patch.
>>
>>    - Addressed (almost) all comments from Vladimir.
>>      - Example styling was not reworked.
>>    - Renamed all filenames to be consistent throughout the document,
>>      fixing a few more file extensions in the process
>>    - Reflowed almost all paragraphs to 78 columns for consistency.
>>    - Changed a few bulleted lists to paragraphs instead
>>    - Changed the big ascii text diagram to a more compact version
>>      and clarified its language
>>    - While in general I prefer to use en_US spellings, I have
>>      replaced "canceled" with "cancelled" so it does not look
>>      out of place juxtaposed with BLOCK_JOB_CANCELLED...
>>
>> Future work that remains to be done:
>>
>> - Paying heed to blockdev-backup workflows
>> - Adding a small migration section explaining the options there
>> - Possibly reworking some of the sections that all make their own
>>    repeated attempts to clarify time interval discretization and adding
>>    a proper treatment of the idea start to finish; this may be neccessary
>>    to explain the two below items properly:
>> - Differential Backups
>> - Pull Backups and NBD
> 
> This all looks a bit more than just "bitmaps.rst". I think at least most of 
> things
> about backups should be separated into backup.rst. (But, please, as a 
> follow-up, if
> you agree).
> 

Yeah, it could certainly be refactored a bit, but the core goal was
"bitmap objects, and the ways you can use them."

It has obviously grown a bit since then, but the push and pull backup
relating parts could go in their own document, maybe.

I'll worry about it later.

Thanks for your help with the reviews!