Re: [PATCH 3/9] ppc/ppc405: Remove CPU

[Nicholas Piggin]

On Sat Jan 11, 2025 at 2:25 AM AEST, Richard Henderson wrote:
> On 1/10/25 08:15, Philippe Mathieu-Daudé wrote:
> > Hi Cédric,
> > 
> > Cc'ing Laurent & Richard for user emulation.
> > 
> ...
> > The deprecation message (see previous patch) was about the
> > "ppc ``ref405ep`` machine". Is that OK we remove these CPUs
> > for user emulation?
> > 
> > $ qemu-ppc -cpu help|fgrep 405
> > PowerPC 405d2            PVR 20010000
> > PowerPC 405gpa           PVR 40110000
> > PowerPC 405gpb           PVR 40110040
> > PowerPC 405cra           PVR 40110041
> > PowerPC 405gpc           PVR 40110082
> > PowerPC 405gpd           PVR 401100c4
> > PowerPC 405gp            (alias for 405gpd)
> > PowerPC 405crb           PVR 401100c5
> > PowerPC 405crc           PVR 40110145
> > PowerPC 405cr            (alias for 405crc)
> > PowerPC 405gpe           (alias for 405crc)
> > PowerPC npe405h          PVR 414100c0
> > PowerPC npe405h2         PVR 41410140
> > PowerPC 405ez            PVR 41511460
> > PowerPC npe405l          PVR 416100c0
> > PowerPC 405d4            PVR 41810000
> > PowerPC 405              (alias for 405d4)
> > PowerPC 405lp            PVR 41f10000
> > PowerPC 405gpr           PVR 50910951
> > PowerPC 405ep            PVR 51210950
>
> Up to the ppc maintainers.  I don't know of anything interesting at the 
> user-only level 
> wrt these cpus.

Just getting back to things after the break...

We are looking at modeling some microcontrollers on the POWER
chips. There is an OCC power management controller which is a 405
and some other weird cut down 405 derivatives, we're not up to
those yet but we want to model them.

We should be able to remove a bunch of boards and CPUs, I just
haven't started looking, so might be easier to wait for a bit.
If it's not causing others too much problem, could we leave this
in for the time being?

Thanks,
Nick