[Qemu-devel] Re: Completing big real mode emulation

[Mohammed Gamal]

On Sat, Mar 20, 2010 at 3:18 PM, Avi Kivity <address@hidden> wrote:
> On 03/20/2010 10:55 AM, Alexander Graf wrote:
>>>
>>>> I'd say that a GSoC project would rather focus on making a guest OS work
>>>> than working on generic big real mode. Having Windows 98 support is way 
>>>> more
>>>> visible to the users. And hopefully more fun to implement too, as it's a
>>>> visible goal :-).
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>> Big real mode allows you to boot various OSes, such as that old
>>> Ubuntu/SuSE boot loader which triggered the whole thing.
>>>
>>
>> I thought legacy Windows uses it too?
>>
>
> IIRC even current Windows (last I checked was XP, but it's probably true for
> newer) invokes big real mode inadvertently.  All it takes is not to clear fs
> and gs while switching to real mode.  It works because the real mode code
> never uses gs and fs (i.e. while we are technically in big real mode, the
> guest never relies on this), and because there are enough hacks in vmx.c to
> make it work (restoring fs and gs after the switch back).  IIRC there are
> other cases of invalid guest state that we hack into place during mode
> switches.
>
>> Either way - then we should make the goal of the project to support those
>> old boot loaders. IMHO it should contain visibility. Doing theoretical stuff
>> is just less fun for all parties. Or does that stuff work already?
>>
>
> Mostly those old guests aged beyond usefulness.  They are still broken, but
> nobody installs new images.  Old images installed via workarounds work.
>
> Goals for this task could include:
>
>  - get those older guests working
>  - get emulate_invalid_guest_state=1 to work on all supported guests
>  - switch to emulate_invalid_guest_state=1 as the default
>  - drop the code supporting emulate_invalid_guest_state=0 eventually

To this end I guess the next logical step is to compile a list of
guests that are currently not working/work with hacks only, and get
them working. Here are some suggestions:
- MINIX 3.1.6 (developers have been recently filing bug reports
because of boot failures)
- Win XP with emulation enabled
- FreeDOS with memory extenders

Any other guests you'd like to see on this list?