Re: Transpose

[David Wright]

On Tue 10 Sep 2019 at 13:19:52 (+0200), John McWilliam wrote:
> Hi again,
>       I attach my attempt to use \modalTranspose in order to save code when 
> rewriting broken chords in C major and A minor.  The idea is to go ahead and 
> repeat the exercise in G major, Eminor etc., however, it looks as though I am 
> going to have to write everything out (longhand). You will see in my example 
> that modalTranspose gives a strange interpretation of A minor and I wonder 
> whether there is a solution to this?

Shouldn't your manual one be:

Aminor = \relative c' {
  \key a \minor
  a4~ a16 c, e a c e, a c e a, c e
}

which matches the modal transposition.

Cheers,
David.