line break at breathe mark (was: Re: no flags replace broken beam)

[Thomas Willhalm]

Mats Bengtsson wrote:
> Thomas Willhalm in gnu.lilypond.bugs wrote:
>> 
>> melodie = \notes \relative c'' {
>>  \partial 2 r8 g g e | g4 g e8()c4. | r8 g' g a g \breathe  \bar "empty"
>> \break
>>  g g e | f4 f d8()b4. | r8 g' g a g \breathe \bar "empty" \break
>>  g g e | g4 g e8()c4. | r8 g' g a g \breathe \bar "empty" \break
>>  g g e | g g g g f d4. | c4 r
>>  \bar "|."
>> }
>> \score {
>>   \context Staff \melodie
>>   \paper { }
>> }
>
> I dare say that your example is fairly non-standard.

I have seen it several times that lines are broken at breathe mark.
In particular, the copy of the attached song was set in this way.
(See
http://www.inf.uni-konstanz.de/~willhalm/misc/WennDasBrotDasWirTeilen.pdf
if you don't want to run lilypond yourself.)

I'm seeking for your advice, whether I should set it in the same way.
In my opinion, it's convenient for singing, but if others are irritated
and find it disturbing, I will change it.

Thanks for your advice
Thomas

WennDasBrotDasWirTeilen.ly
Description: Text document