Re: CodaMark and friends not included in skyline

[Jean Abou Samra]

Le 28/12/2021 à 17:23, Werner LEMBERG a écrit :
> > > I noticed that the following grobs are not part of the skyline.
> > > Actually, I would expect that they are part of it...
> > >
> > >     BarNumber
> > >     CodaMark
> > >     MetronomeMark
> > >     RehearsalMark
> > >     SectionLabel
> > >
> > > Interestingly, `SegnoMark` and `JumpScript` are both part of the
> > > skyline.  The same is true for `CenteredBarNumber`.
> > >
> > > What's the logic behind it?  IMHO, it should be made consistent.
> > > And it should be documented, too.
> > How do you observe this?  I don't see a problem with the
> > debug-skylines output, [...]
> Sorry for not providing an example.  Using Thomas Morley's Scheme code
> I'm extending the `after-line-breaking` property to provide
> documentation links to the NR; see attached example and image.
>
> Note that JumpScript and SegnoMark are affected, too; I made a mistake
> in the code.


Yes. This overrides the default after-line-breaking
callback, which causes trouble if that callback was
supposed to do something important. Harm's code was
written at a time where the grob-transformer was
not available. It's now possible to write this code
in a way that works for grobs with an after-line-breaking
callback. See the attached file. I've also modified
it so that the URL to the documentation is computed
from the version number of the LilyPond version that
runs the file, and not hardcoded.

Best,
Jean

skyline-fixed.ly
Description: Text Data