Re: [Lilypond-auto] Issue 3605 in lilypond: DOC: Bagpipe.ly corrections needed

[lilypond]

Comment #5 on issue 3605 by address@hidden: DOC: Bagpipe.ly  
corrections needed
https://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=3605

Reported by Julia Meihoefer and Oliver Briede :

we attached the corrected bagpipe.ly version 2.19. All changes are  
commented with the introdutction "@JO".

Our corrections are based on research we did for Julias Bachelor Thesis in  
computer engineering 'Identification, notation and reproduction of the  
Great Highland Bagpipe sound' in August 2014. Sources are:

1. Our own long year piping experience with teachers from Germany, Canada  
and Scotland
2.Different literature from the College of Piping (Scotland) and  
McGillivray Piping (Canada)
3. Personal support from the College of Piping (e.g. James MacHattie,  
quoted below):

# Start of quote:
Hi Julia – this is an easy one – BMW is correct in each case!  Lilypond has  
all the top hand strikes incorrect – they should all be done with one  
finger on the top hand, not all fingers.  That explains the low notes in  
Lilypond (incorrect) vs the higher notes in BMW (correct).  I hope that  
makes sense.
Best,
James MacHattie
Director of Education
College of Piping and Celtic Performing Arts of Canada
619 Water Street East
Summerside, PEI, C1N 4H8
902-436-5377
# End of quote

From the Bug Squad: I prepared a patch file (attached)  using meld, but  
haven't created a Reitveld issue because of the pending move and also only  
one .ly being affected.


Attachments:
        0001-PATCH-bagpipe-ly  9.5 KB
        bagpipe_219.ly  13.5 KB

--
You received this message because this project is configured to send all  
issue notifications to this address.
You may adjust your notification preferences at:
https://code.google.com/hosting/settings