Re: [Lilypond-auto] Issue 2764 in lilypond: Fingering placement problem in chords containing a second

[lilypond]

Comment #18 on issue 2764 by address@hidden: Fingering placement  
problem in chords containing a second
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2764

I meant "Needs evidence" to mean that we need an example of what standard  
music engraving would do.

LilyPond gives us two reasonably easy options: stacking fingerings on the  
chord or putting them on individual notes
  {<c' d' e'>2_3_2_1 <c'_1 d'_2 e'_3> }
I have seen both in printed music, Chopin 28:22(Scholtz) is attached,  
Mikuli's edition stacks the fingering vertically.
(The image in comment 17 has the stack on the suspended note D, but it  
should certainly go under the main note-column, so that the fingerings line  
up with the chord in rhythm.)

The original request was, I think, to close up the vertical space when the  
fingerings are in seconds.  Mike had a patch for issue 2527 that does this,  
but it still has a few other problems.

Attachments:
        2764.png  4.0 KB
        Scholtz.png  13.4 KB