Re: How to build and support GRUB for Beaglebone Black?

[Andrei Borzenkov]

09.10.2015 09:04, coadde пишет:
> Andrei Borzenkov:
> > How do you start GRUB in the first place? On U-Boot platforms GRUB
> > cannot be run without U-Boot at all (it relies on U-Boot API for
> > disk/net IO), so the simplest way to get back to U-Boot is to exit GRUB :)
> >
> > Otherwise please explain in more details how you build and start GRUB on
> > this platform.
>
> I built grub under this configuration (GRUB for U-Boot platforms):
>
>         ./autogen.sh
>
>         ./configure \
>                 --with-platform="uboot" \
>                 --target="arm" \

OK so you have arm-uboot target. This target requires U-Boot; i.e. 
U-Boot starts GRUB. Let's say you are now in GRUB CLI.

Unfortunately I still fail to understand what you are want to achieve. 
Do you want to get back to U-Boot? Do you try to load and jump to 
completely new U-Boot binary? In the latter case what is the reason for 
it (if you needed U-Boot you could just not load GRUB).

>                 --disable-efiemu \
>                 --enable-mm-debug \
>                 --enable-nls \
>                 --enable-device-mapper \
>                 --enable-cache-stats \
>                 --enable-boot-time \
>                 --enable-grub-mkfont \
>                 --enable-grub-mount \
>                 --prefix="/usr" \
>                 --bindir="/usr/bin" \
>                 --sbindir="/usr/bin" \
>                 --mandir="/usr/share/man" \
>                 --infodir="/usr/share/info" \
>                 --datarootdir="/usr/share" \
>                 --sysconfdir="/etc" \
>                 --program-prefix="" \
>                 --with-bootdir="/boot" \
>                 --with-grubdir="grub" \
>                 --disable-silent-rules \
>                 --disable-werror
>
>         make
>
>
> Those configurations comes from our grub's PKGBUILD [0] and our patch to
> detect device tree folder [1]. Those files were created to build grub
> for Parabola.
>
> BTW, i created 2 U-Boot packages, the first one called
> uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre to start up U-Boot without GRUB for our
> linux-libre package. Here are the PKGBUILD [2] and a custom patch with
> our custom modifications [3] based on uboot-beaglebone from Arch ARM
> [4][5]. It was tested and works well in Parabola, also we put a
> announcement [6] about it.
>
> Note: we put linux-libre as suffix in our uboot-beaglebone package for
> each specific kernel available in Parabola (eg.
> uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre-lts for linux-libre-lts) because our kernel
> images use custom names (eg. vmlinuz-linux-libre-grsec) in comparison to
> Arch ARM (eg zImage for all kernels) to allow for 2 or more kernels in
> the same system once we add GRUB compatibility for the future.
>
> The second one is called uboot-grub-beaglebone, this uboot package was
> created to start GRUB in ARMv7, it was based on
> uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre. Here are our PKGBUILD [7] and patch [8]
> for this package.
>
> Otherwise, we've created a install file to install GRUB automatically
> after installing [9], it was based on uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre too [10]
>
> [0]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre/grub/PKGBUILD
> [1]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/tree/libre/grub/grub-10_linux-20_linux_xen-detect-devicetree-dir.patch
> [2]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre/uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre/PKGBUILD
> [3]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre/uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre/0001-parabola-arm-modifications.patch
> [4]:https://raw.githubusercontent.com/archlinuxarm/PKGBUILDs/master/alarm/uboot-beaglebone/PKGBUILD
> [5]:https://github.com/archlinuxarm/PKGBUILDs/blob/master/alarm/uboot-beaglebone/0001-arch-linux-arm-modifications.patch
> [6]:https://www.parabola.nu/news/parabola-supports-armv7/
> [7]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre-testing/uboot-grub-beaglebone/PKGBUILD
> [8]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre-testing/uboot-grub-beaglebone/0001-parabola-arm-modifications+grub-support.patch
> [9]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre-testing/uboot-grub-beaglebone/uboot-grub-beaglebone.install
> [10]:https://projects.parabola.nu/abslibre.git/plain/libre/uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre/uboot-beaglebone-linux-libre.install
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Help-grub mailing list
> address@hidden
> https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/help-grub