[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
REWRITE of " Recovering from _misinstall_ of GRUB 1.98"
From: |
Richard Owlett |
Subject: |
REWRITE of " Recovering from _misinstall_ of GRUB 1.98" |
Date: |
Thu, 16 Feb 2012 09:10:04 -0600 |
User-agent: |
Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.9.1.13) Gecko/20100914 SeaMonkey/2.0.8 |
I've received "on list" and "off list" replies which
demonstrate that where I did not confuse the reader I
inspired them to answer questions I wasn't asking. So I'll
do a complete rewrite using high school journalism questions
of 50+ years ago.
Who - a Linux newbie
What - two computers - WinXP Pro installed, BIOS allows
booting from USB device
a Lenovo (IBM) ThinkCentre whose only internet
connection is dialup
a Lenovo (IBM) ThinkPad with dialup and WiFi
connectivity
"live cd" of Ubuntu 10.10 (includes GNU GRUB version
1.98)
a blank USB stick
Goal - Linux on a bootable USB stick such that I could
seamlessly switch between
machines depending on which was more convenient
without context loss.
*RESTRICTION* - _NOTHING_ written to hard drive (no dual boot)!
Attempted installation by following menu prompts. I was
allowed to install to a removable device and specify that
all of the space on that device was to be used. My
assumption (which proved false) was if an OS was to placed
on a removable device, it would be bootable.
Symptoms:
1. on system boot a menu is presented offering choice of OS.
*FAILURE* project specification was "no dual boot"!
2. when forced to dual boot was not given option of
specifying default OS.
3. when USB stick not inserted boot fails although BIOS is
told to boot from
internal hard drive - expectation of booting Windows.
Grub crashes to "rescue mode".
4. when USB stick is inserted in second machine and BIOS
instructed to boot
from external device - it doesn't.
Diagnosis:
1. Grub installed to hard drive where it *does NOT belong*.
2. Grub *NOT* installed to USB stick where it is needed.
Original requests:
How to remove grub from hard drive and repair MBR if required?
How to get grub unto USB stick?
MS Windows Recovery Disk is option of last resort for first
due to data loss danger.
I've been led to a temporary solution of second by booting
up usb Ubuntu and at terminal
$ sudo grub-install /dev/sdb
It "functions", if strangely. The menu "allows" booting from
copy of Ubuntu of USB stick or booting copy of Windows on a
machine that may be miles away ;/
In response to Mr. Dupree, I've a copy of SystemRescueCD and
a collection of LiveCd's of several Linux distros.