[gnugo-devel] endgame contest

[Paul Pogonyshev]

here are the results of endgame contest between 3.2 and 3.4
(cvs very close to 3.4).  the results are very good.  not
only 3.4 won far more games than 3.2, 3.4 is also much less
likely to play an endgame blunder (judging by results).

positive differences are good for "white" (3.4).

sgf records are available on request.

Paul


../games/honinbo/honinbo-1941-2.sgf: B+1.0 B+2.0; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1941-3.sgf: W+9.0 W+1.0; difference +8.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1941-5.sgf: same result: B+10.0
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1945-1.sgf: same result: W+6.0
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1945-2.sgf: same result: W+3.0
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1945-3.sgf: B+3.0 B+36.0; difference +33.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1945-4.sgf: B+3.0 B+4.0; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1945-p1.sgf: W+7.0 B+7.0; difference +14.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1945-p2.sgf: W+3.5 B+0.5; difference +4.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1947-1.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        B+1.5 B+2.5
        B+6.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1947-2.sgf: B+9.5 B+8.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1947-3.sgf: same result: W+4.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1947-4.sgf: B+1.5 W+0.5; difference -2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1947-5.sgf: W+123.5 B+7.5; difference +131.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1950-1.sgf: same result: W+7.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1950-2.sgf: B+1.5 W+1.5; difference -3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1950-3.sgf: W+6.5 W+1.5; difference +5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1951-2.sgf: B+2.5 B+7.5; difference +5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1951-3.sgf: B+2.5 B+19.5; difference +17.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1951-5.sgf: same result: W+12.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1951-6.sgf: B+10.5 B+11.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1951-7.sgf: same result: B+3.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1952-2.sgf: W+9.5 W+6.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1952-4.sgf: W+4.5 W+5.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1953-1.sgf: W+0.5 B+10.5; difference +11.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1953-2.sgf: B+1.5 B+0.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1953-3.sgf: W+5.5 W+0.5; difference +5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1953-5.sgf: B+3.5 B+2.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1954-2.sgf: W+2.5 B+3.5; difference +6.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1954-3.sgf: B+3.5 B+4.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1954-6.sgf: W+2.5 W+1.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1955-1.sgf: B+1.5 B+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1955-2.sgf: W+2.5 W+3.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1956-1.sgf: W+6.5 W+5.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1956-6.sgf: B+1.5 B+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1957-1.sgf: W+3.5 W+0.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1957-2.sgf: same result: W+1.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1957-6.sgf: W+3.5 W+4.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1958-3.sgf: B+1.5 B+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1958-6.sgf: same result: B+1.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1959-2.sgf: same result: B+1.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1959-3.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+1.5
        W+0.5 W+1.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1959-5.sgf: W+18.5 W+12.5; difference +6.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1960-2.sgf: W+26.5 W+0.5; difference +26.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1960-4.sgf: same result: W+2.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1960-6.sgf: W+2.5 W+0.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1961-2.sgf: W+5.5 W+1.5; difference +4.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1961-3.sgf: B+0.5 B+1.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1961-4.sgf: B+12.5 B+13.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1961-5.sgf: B+0.5 W+9.5; difference -10.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1962-3.sgf: B+5.5 B+8.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1962-4.sgf: B+5.5 B+11.5; difference +6.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1962-5.sgf: W+0.5 B+0.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1963-1.sgf: same result: B+22.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1963-4.sgf: W+1.5 W+0.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1963-5.sgf: W+2.5 W+0.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1964-1.sgf: W+3.5 W+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1965-4.sgf: B+7.5 B+8.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1966-2.sgf: B+0.5 B+7.5; difference +7.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1967-1.sgf: W+3.5 W+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1967-4.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+16.5
        W+16.5 W+15.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1967-5.sgf: W+31.5 W+5.5; difference +26.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1968-2.sgf: same result: B+9.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1968-3.sgf: same result: W+11.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1968-4.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+2.5
        W+1.5 W+0.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1968-6.sgf: W+2.5 W+0.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1968-7.sgf: W+2.5 W+1.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1969-2.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+7.5 W+6.5
        W+2.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1970-1.sgf: W+4.5 W+2.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1970-2.sgf: W+1.5 W+0.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1970-3.sgf: W+6.5 B+11.5; difference +18.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1970-4.sgf: B+0.5 B+1.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1971-2.sgf: B+0.5 B+1.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1971-6.sgf: W+0.5 B+1.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1972-3.sgf: W+6.5 W+5.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1972-4.sgf: W+15.5 W+2.5; difference +13.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1972-6.sgf: W+8.5 B+7.5; difference +16.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1972-7.sgf: W+5.5 W+4.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1973-4.sgf: B+4.5 B+8.5; difference +4.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1974-1.sgf: same result: B+9.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1974-6.sgf: same result: B+6.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1975-2.sgf: B+1.5 B+3.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1975-3.sgf: B+7.5 B+10.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1975-6.sgf: W+15.5 W+86.5; difference -71.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1975-7.sgf: W+24.5 W+23.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1976-1.sgf: B+1.5 B+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1976-2.sgf: W+19.5 W+5.5; difference +14.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1976-4.sgf: B+3.5 B+7.5; difference +4.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1978-2.sgf: B+5.5 B+0.5; difference -5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1978-3.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        B+37.5
        B+8.5 B+9.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1978-4.sgf: B+2.5 B+5.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1978-5.sgf: B+12.5 B+10.5; difference -2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1978-6.sgf: W+4.5 W+3.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1979-4.sgf: W+2.5 B+0.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1980-1.sgf: W+3.5 W+0.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1981-3.sgf: same result: W+3.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1981-6.sgf: B+3.5 B+4.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1982-2.sgf: W+8.5 W+4.5; difference +4.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1982-3.sgf: W+6.5 W+4.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1982-4.sgf: same result: W+11.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1982-5.sgf: B+3.5 B+6.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1983-3.sgf: W+7.5 W+5.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1984-3.sgf: W+3.5 W+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1985-3.sgf: W+10.5 W+5.5; difference +5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1985-5.sgf: same result: B+2.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1986-1.sgf: W+3.5 W+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1986-2.sgf: W+3.5 W+1.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1987-1.sgf: same result: B+5.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1987-4.sgf: W+0.5 W+33.5; difference -33.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1988-3.sgf: B+4.5 B+5.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1988-4.sgf: B+4.5 B+6.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1990-3.sgf: B+1.5 B+6.5; difference +5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1990-5.sgf: same result: W+7.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1990-6.sgf: B+4.5 B+0.5; difference -4.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1990-7.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+4.5 W+3.5
        W+2.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1991-2.sgf: B+3.5 B+6.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1991-3.sgf: B+9.5 B+10.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1991-4.sgf: W+7.5 W+5.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1991-5.sgf: B+3.5 B+4.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1992-4.sgf: B+8.5 B+7.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1992-7.sgf: B+6.5 B+11.5; difference +5.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1993-1.sgf: B+6.5 B+7.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1993-2.sgf: B+2.5 B+3.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1993-3.sgf: B+2.5 B+3.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1993-4.sgf: W+5.5 W+3.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1994-1.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        B+0.5 B+1.5
        B+5.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1994-3.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+17.5 W+16.5
        B+37.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1994-7.sgf: B+1.5 B+15.5; difference +14.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1995-1.sgf: W+4.5 W+3.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1995-3.sgf: W+5.5 W+2.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1996-1.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        B+7.5 B+9.5
        B+10.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1996-5.sgf: W+3.5 W+2.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1996-6.sgf: W+3.5 W+4.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1997-3.sgf: can't determine difference, engines 
disagreed on results.
        W+16.5 W+15.5
        W+16.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1999-1.sgf: B+4.5 B+5.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1999-3.sgf: B+3.5 B+47.5; difference +44.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1999-4.sgf: W+0.5 B+2.5; difference +3.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-1999-5.sgf: W+4.5 W+3.5; difference +1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-2000-2.sgf: B+0.5 B+2.5; difference +2.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-2000-3.sgf: W+2.5 W+3.5; difference -1.0.
../games/honinbo/honinbo-2000-5.sgf: same result: W+1.5
../games/honinbo/honinbo-2000-6.sgf: B+6.5 B+13.5; difference +7.0.

+1.0
+8.0
0
0
0
+33.0
+1.0
+14.0
+4.0
unknown
-1.0
0
-2.0
+131.0
0
-3.0
+5.0
+5.0
+17.0
0
+1.0
0
+3.0
-1.0
+11.0
-1.0
+5.0
-1.0
+6.0
+1.0
+1.0
+1.0
-1.0
+1.0
+1.0
+3.0
0
-1.0
+1.0
0
0
unknown
+6.0
+26.0
0
+2.0
+4.0
+1.0
+1.0
-10.0
+3.0
+6.0
+1.0
0
+1.0
+2.0
+1.0
+1.0
+7.0
+1.0
unknown
+26.0
0
0
unknown
+2.0
+1.0
unknown
+2.0
+1.0
+18.0
+1.0
+1.0
+2.0
+1.0
+13.0
+16.0
+1.0
+4.0
0
0
+2.0
+3.0
-71.0
+1.0
+1.0
+14.0
+4.0
-5.0
unknown
+3.0
-2.0
+1.0
+3.0
+3.0
0
+1.0
+4.0
+2.0
0
+3.0
+2.0
+1.0
+5.0
0
+1.0
+2.0
0
-33.0
+1.0
+2.0
+5.0
0
-4.0
unknown
+3.0
+1.0
+2.0
+1.0
-1.0
+5.0
+1.0
+1.0
+1.0
+2.0
unknown
unknown
+14.0
+1.0
+3.0
unknown
+1.0
-1.0
unknown
+1.0
+44.0
+3.0
+1.0
+2.0
-1.0
0
+7.0

Total 142 game(s) replayed. White won 92. Black won 17.
White: 5083.400s CPU time.

Time control report (wall move generation time):
  White: 63:05.5
  Black: 58:57.8