Re: [Fsfe-uk] Symbian reanimates software patent debate

[Alex Hudson]

MJ Ray wrote:
> It's somewhat worrying that VNU report it as "Symbian's win could
> benefit UK software makers" when there will be N makers hurt for every
> one that benefits.  I'll drop a short comment to them.
>   

I don't want to be too conspiratorial about it, but I do think this has 
been somewhat planned amongst those wishing for software patents - 
things have gone quiet in this country on that front, and they're trying 
again while they think they have cover. Not at all surprising that the 
press is completely one-sided, since there's only one side arguing the 
case now.

> > Hopefully, if we in the UK can get our act together, we can stop this 
> > from getting approved: I don't think this patent is very strong, 
> > particularly for the above reason.
> >     
>
> I agree.  How can we help stop this?  If no-one beats me to it, I'll
> ask UKPTO/IPO.  Ironically, I know more about the European PO and
> USPTO than how the UK system works.
>   

Well, the next step is to ensure that UKIPO appeal the decision to the 
appeals court, and somehow try to make sure that their appeal is upheld. 
FFII-UK is in the process of getting its act together, so I suggest that 
they are the people to lead on this, but there is definitely going to be 
a man-power issue.

To what extent outsiders can get involved in the appeal I don't know, 
and obviously it's not something you can particularly lobby :/

Cheers,

Alex.