Re: A few changes to test in master

[Bastien]

Hi Jack,

Jack Kamm <address@hidden> writes:

> Bastien <address@hidden> writes:
>
>> - M-x org-table-electric-header-mode RET will display the first row
>>   of the table at point in the header line when the first row is not
>>   visible anymore.
>
> This is great, it's a huge quality-of-life improvement for working with
> long tables. Below are some issues I noticed when playing with it.

Thanks for testing and taking the trouble to report these issues.

> The variable `org-table-header-line-p' doesn't seem to have any effect
> for me, I find that I need to call "M-x org-table-header-line-mode" even
> when it's set.

Should be fixed now.

> Also, "M-x org-table-header-line-mode" seems to activate the minor mode
> globally, despite a message suggesting it is only activated in the
> current buffer. Maybe because we use "defvar" instead of "defvar-local"
> to define its variable?
>
> I tried replacing the "defvar" with "defvar-local", it seemed to fix the
> global activation of the minor mode, but still it seems the hooks added
> are still active in other org buffers. So if I activate the mode in
> buffer A, then view a long table in buffer B, I see the table header
> when scrolling through it, even though the mode isn't active in B.

Well, I tried various things and I didn't fix this one.  Perhaps this
is due to the special display of the header line.  I will continue to
look for a solution.

> If I am in a table, and scroll-up-command brings me out of the table,
> then the header of the table still sits on top of the window immediately
> after scrolling. This gets fixed as soon as any action is taken
> (e.g. moving the cursor or hitting C-g).

Yes, this happened to me sometimes.  I think I enhanced the situation
a bit here, but I can't tell for 100% sure.  Please test and report.

> It would be nice if the header row was a little more visually
> distinguishable from the other table rows (maybe by adding an underline
> to that row?)

Good idea, done - you can now customize the face:

M-x customize-face RET org-table-header RET

> Feature request (for Org 9.5?):
>
> It would be great if an analogous feature could be added for the
> left-most column of a table, so if a table is very wide, and I scroll to
> the right, I could still see which row index I'm in.

Yes.  I am still trying to precisely see the problem and solve it in a
way that's not too invasive.

Best,

-- 
 Bastien