Re: [O] Feature request - Decouple org's keybindings from their functions

[mithraeum]

On Tuesday, November 27, 2018 12:02 AM, Nicolas Goaziou <address@hidden> wrote:
>
> Are you talking about Org a whole, or just Org agenda? All your examples
> are about the latter. If it's about Org agenda, well, I'm afraid to say
> there are so many things to fix there that keybindings are only the tip
> of the iceberg.

I thought org-agenda was part of org.  It's org-agenda which I've been going 
through recently to bind in to hydras, so that's why I used it as an example.  
I hope the principle of separating functions from bindings applies to the rest 
of org as well, though.

> Hydra is very opinionated about what a menu is. It may not be a good
> default. Also, it doesn't ship with Emacs. So Org cannot rely on it from
> the start.

I can understand how hydra not being shipped with Emacs would preclude it from 
being used by Org.  Maybe it could inspire the way Org handles menuing, 
however.  As opinionated as it might be, it's very flexible and powerful, and 
its keybindings and menus are clearly separated from the functions they invoke.

But if there is something even better and cleaner than hydra, I'd be all for it.