[Orgmode] Re: Bug fix: org-mhe links don't work with mairix

[Thomas Baumann]

Hi Nick,

your patch actually breaks namazu, swish and grep searches. 

A look at mh-search-choices (mh-search.el) reveals that for namazu,
swish and grep mh-search-regexp-builder is nil and therefore 

(funcall mh-search-regexp-builder ...

raises an error. One might be tempted to solve this on the mh-e side but
there's no reason to add a mh-search-regexp-builder for those search
engines. There's a patch against todays git below.

BTW. Namazu and pick searches work fine without angular brackets, however, it
doesn't harm to have them.


Greetings
Thomas


--- /data/cvs/org-mode/lisp/org-mhe.el  2008-05-17 12:54:07.000000000 +0200
+++ org-mhe.el  2008-05-17 16:55:22.000000000 +0200
@@ -204,8 +204,10 @@
                      (not (org-mhe-get-message-real-folder)))
             (kill-this-buffer)
             (mh-search "+" (list "--message-id" article))))
-      (mh-search "+" (funcall mh-search-regexp-builder
-                             (list (cons 'message-id article)))))
+      (if mh-search-regexp-builder
+          (mh-search "+" (funcall mh-search-regexp-builder
+                             (list (cons 'message-id article))))
+        (mh-search "+" article)))
     (if (org-mhe-get-message-real-folder)
         (mh-show-msg 1)
       (kill-this-buffer)


Nick Dokos <address@hidden> writes:

> Pete Phillips had run into a problem back in November 2007 with mhe
> links to emails not working (he was using mairix as the mh search
> method). I just sent a patch to Bill Wohler about the mh-e part (and
> copied both the mh-e list and the org list: the problem is described in
> more detail there). Here is the org-mode patch.
>
> I've tested the patch both with the default "pick" search in mh-e and
> with "mairix" search. Pete Phillips also did some testing (I believe
> with mairix) - thanks Pete!
>
> I would feel better if there had been some swish++/namazu/etc testing as
> well, but it's unlikely that I'll find the time in the foreseeable
> future. In particular, I'm not sure where the angle brackets are needed:
> it's clear they are needed for the pick search and I've found out that
> they are *not* needed for mairix search, but if swish++ needs them, that
> would complicate things. The patch assumes that they are not needed for
> any search method, other than pick. If somebody on the list could try it
> and report success/failure, I, for one, would appreciate it very much.
>
> If it looks OK to you, could you please apply it?
>
> Thanks very much,
> Nick
>
> --- a/lisp/org-mhe.el
> +++ b/lisp/org-mhe.el
> @@ -194,16 +194,16 @@ folders."
>    (mh-find-path)
>    (if (not article)
>        (mh-visit-folder (mh-normalize-folder-name folder))
> -    (setq article (org-add-angle-brackets article))
>      (mh-search-choose)
>      (if (equal mh-searcher 'pick)
>          (progn
> +          (setq article (org-add-angle-brackets article))
>            (mh-search folder (list "--message-id" article))
>            (when (and org-mhe-search-all-folders
>                       (not (org-mhe-get-message-real-folder)))
>              (kill-this-buffer)
>              (mh-search "+" (list "--message-id" article))))
> -      (mh-search "+" article))
> +      (mh-search "+" (funcall mh-search-regexp-builder (list (cons 
> 'message-id article)))))
>      (if (org-mhe-get-message-real-folder)
>          (mh-show-msg 1)
>        (kill-this-buffer)
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Emacs-orgmode mailing list
> Remember: use `Reply All' to send replies to the list.
> address@hidden
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/emacs-orgmode