Re: Fingering not aligned in 2.17, ok in 2.16

[Thomas Scharkowski]

-------- Original-Nachricht --------

> Nick Payne writes:
>
> > > Do you consider this a bug?  Actually, I like the new behaviour
> > > better.  What does the literature say?
> >
> > The great majority of commercial guitar scores I possess align the
> > fingering vertically on chords, as 2.16 does.
>
> Which means that there is no strict agreement?  The great majority
> have been wrong before.
>
> What about the most beautiful scores amongst your collection, what do
> they do?
>
> Jan
Most of the newer commercial guitar score are poorly typeset imho.
Compare the old Schott edition (hand engraved) of Ponce's "Thème varié 
et finale" and the new one which was made using Finale.

On topic: I like the new behaviour better.
there is a nice example where sometimes the fingerings are aligned and 
sometimes not, for better readability:
Goffredo Petrassi: Nunc (1971), Edizioni Suvini Zerboni (c) 1972

Thomas