[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals
From: |
Frédéric Bron |
Subject: |
Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals |
Date: |
Thu, 29 Oct 2009 10:57:27 +0100 |
> Under this premise, I think it makes sense to inherit the key signature.
> Now if we have _within_ a voice << { xxx } \\ { yyy } >>, what does this
> mean? Since the purpose of "voice" accidental style is to write stuff
> that several different people read, this corresponds to splitting a
> tenor voice (for example). This means that the split voices should not
> just inherit the key signature, but also already preexisting accidentals
> of the "father voice" since obviously the same persons are singing tenor
> 1 and tenor 2 that have been singing tenor previously. Also, any
> accidental changes within xxx and yyy need to be consolidated into the
> following rejoined voice: if there are different accidentals in xxx and
> yyy for a note, a recurrence of the note after the split needs a
> cautionary accidental.
Good point.
So this would not be the case for voice style (apart from heriting the
key signature) but for modern-voice it would be OK as the cancellation
is at Staff context.
Frédéric
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, (continued)
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Valentin Villenave, 2009/10/26
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Frédéric Bron, 2009/10/25
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Trevor Daniels, 2009/10/25
- Re: [spam probable] Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Frédéric Bron, 2009/10/26
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Trevor Daniels, 2009/10/26
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Mats Bengtsson, 2009/10/26
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Frédéric Bron, 2009/10/29
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, David Kastrup, 2009/10/29
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals,
Frédéric Bron <=
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Neil Puttock, 2009/10/25
- Re: automatic accidental style voice: too many written accidentals, Frédéric Bron, 2009/10/26