bug#14008: Better autoindent for C++11 code?

[Stefan Kangas]

Hi Alan,

Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> writes:

>> > C++11 introduced lambda syntax []() { ... } and other strange things that 
>> > Emacs indents strangely.
>
>> > for_each(range.begin(), range.end(), [=](int i) {
>> >     cout << strings[i] << endl;
>> >   });
>
>> > I would like the final line `});` to have the same indentation level
>> > as the first line `for_each...`.
>
>> I'm seeing the same thing here.
>
> I think this is the minimum indentation imposed on all lines within "code
> blocks" in "gnu" style.  (See the CC Mode manual for a description of CC
> Mode's style system.)  If you indent the for_each line by, say, 4 columns
> (put it inside braces if needed) the line with }); then gets indented
> under the for_each.  As for_each is a function (pretty much equivalent to
> Lisp's mapc), it's unlikely to be put at column 0 in real source code.

Indeed.  It seems to work better when you put it in a function.

>> > Here's another example:
>
>> > for_each(range.begin(), range.end(), [&](int i) {
>> >              std::async(
>> >                         launch::async,
>> >                         [&]() { strings[i] = fizzy(i); }
>> >                         );
>> >   });
>
>> > The arguments to std::async and its closing parenthesis are indented
>> > much too far; I would like them indented only one level further than
>> > where std::async is itself indented. Any tips for achieving this?
>
> Configure CC Mode, either by activating a different style (with C-c ., or
> M-x c-set-style if some minor mode is using that key binding), or by
> directly setting syntactic symbols' "offsets".
[...]
> Again, I strongly recommend reading the relevant pages in the CC Mode
> manual.
[...]
>> Perhaps Alan could clarify if this is a bug or if this is just a case
>> of missing configuration?
>
> A bit of a mixture of both, I think.

Do you think there is anything more to do here, or should this bug be
closed?

Best regards,
Stefan Kangas