Re: [Bug-gnupedia]censorship

[Dries van Oosten]

On Wed, 17 Jan 2001, Tom Tollenaere wrote:

> > Will an article be
> > refused if a reviewer doesn't approve or will it be published with a bad
> grade?
>
> > Groeten,
> > Dries
>
> I don't think any one person should have the right to refuse an
> article.  We could set a limit, like any article that gets more than x
> bad reviews gets booted.  Number of bad review should be visible next
> the the article's heading, of course.

But should it not also be possible to defend oneself?
Do good review compensate for bad reviews?
If so, all reviewers should be registered, to avoid double counting bad or
good counts. Will the registering then scare away potential reviewers?
You should realize how much complexity you just added to the project
*grin*.

Groeten,
Dries